Why Drones Win

Amitai Etzioni on why, in terms of morality and efficiency, drones win hands down.

By: /
10 December, 2012
By: Amitai Etzioni
Director of the Institute for Communitarian Policy Studies at The George Washington University

As I see it, one must separate the question of whether a given person ought to be killed (morally and legally speaking) from the question of how this should be done (i.e. using what tools), if s/he is to be killed legitimately. As I have suggested elsewhere, compared to other tools – whether Special Forces, missiles, or bombs – drones are the preferred means by far. They allow for a much more careful review of the target, limit collateral damage, and reduce the casualties on our side.

MORE FROM THIS SERIES

Given these facts, it seems odd to me for anyone to imply that drones should not be employed because of the danger of contagion. If other nations use them for legitimate kills, more power to them. If they use them for illegitimate kills, it would not be better or worse than if they had used other technologies (see Syria). And if they use drones to achieve goals other than killing terrorists, so be it. (Some are now used for locating lost skiers…)

The notion that if the U.S. did not develop and popularize the production and deployment of this technology that other nations would not do so, is questionable. China, for instance, is “popularizing” anti-ship missiles (followed by Iran) and cyber spying (followed by the U.S.). The question ought to be whether the goal is legitimate, and whether the means are preferable to others. In terms of morality and efficiency, drones win, hands down.

Before you click away, we’d like to ask you for a favour … 

 

Open Canada is published by the Canadian International Council, but that’s only the beginning of what the CIC does. Through its research and live events hosted by its 18 branches across the country, the CIC is dedicated to engaging Canadians from all walks of life in an ongoing conversation about Canada’s place in the world.

By becoming a member, you’ll be joining a community of Canadians who seek to shape Canada’s role in the world, and you’ll help Open Canada continue to publish thoughtful and provocative reporting and analysis.

Join us

Also in the series

Drones for Human Rights

Drones for Human Rights

By:

Christopher Tuckwood on why UAVs should be added to the human rights tool box.

Gregory Johnsen on Yemen, the U.S., and Drones

Gregory Johnsen on Yemen, the U.S., and Drones

By:

OpenCanada’s interview with the author of The Last Refuge.

Where Drones Fit in Fields of Violence

Where Drones Fit in Fields of Violence

By:

There are serious concerns to navigate when it comes to the political geography of remote warfare.

The View From the Ground

The View From the Ground

By:

Renee Filiatrault on what it means to have an eye in the sky for the boots on the ground.

Are Drones Right for Canada?

Are Drones Right for Canada?

By:

Major-General Fraser Holman (Retired) on how Canada might best make use of UAV technology.

Drone Knowns and Unknowns

Drone Knowns and Unknowns

By:

Joshua Foust on why the discussion around drone strikes is muddled and vague at best.

The Case for Humanitarian Drones

The Case for Humanitarian Drones

By:

Jack C. Chow on how drones can dramatically change aid – if only we can overcome the stigma associated with them.

The Case Against Humanitarian Drones

The Case Against Humanitarian Drones

By:

Nathaniel A. Raymond, Brittany Card, and Ziad Al Achkar on why drones should not be deployed in humanitarian operations

Letting Drones Reach their Potential

Letting Drones Reach their Potential

By:

Ryan Calo on why the potential uses of drones for good are endless and should be protected from citizen backlash.

The Slow Death of the ‘Non-Combatant’

The Slow Death of the ‘Non-Combatant’

By:

Jennifer Welsh on how targeting processes for drone strikes challenges how we traditionally distinguish non-combatants in war.

The Robotics Revolution

The Robotics Revolution

By:

Brookings senior fellow Peter W. Singer on the broader implications of the use of drones for surveillance and war.

Drones For Good

Drones For Good

By:

Matthew Schroyer on why so many people get drones wrong – they’re not all heartless, pilotless killing machines.

Drone Proliferation

Drone Proliferation

By:

Denis Stairs on why the proliferation of military drones could be both a stabilizing and destabilizing force.

Lethal Drones

Lethal Drones

By:

Council on Foreign Relations fellow Micah Zenko on how UAVs are a different kind of weapon, and one that is quickly proliferating.

Drones in the Field

Drones in the Field

By:

From kamikaze killers to stealth stalkers, OpenCanada runs through the ways drones are being used in the field today.