In Canada, now is the time to ban the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh network
Islamophobia resulting from an imported supremacist ideology must not be allowed to grow.
At a 2013 parade in Udaipur, India, portraits of the founders of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, K. B. Hedgewar and M. S. Golwalkar are displayed. Image by: Daniel Villafruela/Pixabay.
Last month, the Government of Canada made the unprecedented move of expelling six diplomats linked to India’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) for ties to criminal activities on Canadian soil, including extortion, coercion, and even murder. India quickly denied such links and responded by ordering six Canadian diplomats to go home including the acting high commissioner.
The decision to expel the six diplomats from Canada came a year after national headlines were made by the killing of prominent British Columbia Sikh community leader Hardeep Singh Nijjar, for which Prime Minister Trudeau himself ended up accusing the BJP of unlawful involvement.
What many might not know is that the BJP, which has dominated Indian politics for a decade, is the political arm of a much older, perhaps even more consequential, parent organization called the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), a paramilitary group founded in 1925 that has consistently called for the persecution of India’s religious minorities, including Sikhs, Christians, Dalits, Muslims, and others. Early RSS ideologues cited European fascists like Adolf Hitler as a positive model. India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi himself is a life-long RSS member, as are many BJP officials.
As the Bridge Initiative at Georgetown University notes, “the RSS has been at the forefront of promoting Hindu-nationalism in India,” and is accused of inciting “violence against India’s Dalit-Bahujan community, including hate crimes against Muslims, lynchings of Dalits, and pogroms against religious minorities.”
While today’s RSS has attempted to distance itself from its past activities, the evidence is overwhelming that this is not the case. Under Canada’s Anti-Terrorism Act, an organization need only commit terrorism somewhere in the world to end up as a banned entity. The RSS and its broad network have accumulated a prolific resume in this sense.
For example, in February 2020, around 40 Muslims were killed by Islamophobic mobs in the city of New Delhi. They were peacefully protesting the BJP government’s new immigration laws. According to Human Rights Watch (HRW), “top BJP leaders dangerously derided the protestors, and some openly called for violence against them.” Other RSS members also confirmed with Indian journalists that they deliberately took part in the violence.
Another example involves the infamous case of Monu Manesar, a member of the prominent RSS affiliate Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP)’s youth wing, the Bajrang Dal, who is infamous for live streaming himself attacking Indian Muslims. He was arrested last fall as the prime suspect in the murder of two Muslim men and for inciting violence against Muslims in Haryana last summer.
A prominent example of communal violence involving BJP officials is Yogi Adityanath, Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh since 2017. He started his RSS activism in college by joining its youth wing before moving up the BJP ranks. As documented by Amnesty International, Adityanath is infamous for (among other things) deploying bulldozers against Muslim activists who dissent against the BJP’s often sectarian governance. This has earned him the moniker, “Bulldozer Baba.” Just this month, India’s Supreme Court finally banned the usage of bulldozers as a punitive measure.
Other examples include BJP lawmaker Haribhushan Thakur Bachaul, who in 2022 called openly for India’s Muslims to be set on fire, comparing them to “demons.” Or BJP parliamentarian and former Cabinet Minister Anurag Thakur, who was censored during an election campaign by India’s Election Commission for inciting a crowd with chants of “What should be done to traitors of the country?”—to which the crowd replied with, “Shoot them!” The chants were referring to those who opposed the BJP’s Citizenship (Amendment) Act, which has been widely criticized for singling out India’s Muslim refugees as the only group shut out of a faster track to citizenship.
Moreover, the RSS and the VHP were explicitly named in another damning HRW report for being the groups “most directly responsible” in the infamous 2002 anti-Muslim pogrom in the state of Gujarat. The violence is among the most notorious examples in modern Indian history and ended in the deaths of over 1,000 Muslims.
In 1992, VHP members also took part in large violent mobs that destroyed the 16th century Babri Mosque in the city of Ayodhya, Uttar Pradesh. The incident sparked mass anti-Muslim violence across Northern India, resulting in the deaths of around 1,000 people, according to HRW. The incident was widely covered by the international press, including the BBC, which refers to the RSS as the “ideological fountainhead” for groups involved in the Babri incident.
The VHP, also known as the World Hindu Council, along with other RSS-affiliated groups, operates in Canada as an Ontario-based registered (and thus tax exempt) charity. It is an open affiliate of the larger RSS global network. Unfortunately, the VHP isn’t the only sign that this troubling ideology and network has long been operational throughout Canada.
The RSS’s main foreign group, the Hindu Swayamsevak Sangh, or HSS, has chapters across Canada, from British Columbia to Nova Scotia. Since 1991, they have also been a registered charity in Canada.
In November 2022, the inaugural year of Hindu Heritage Month in Canada, a crowd led by MP Chandra Arya raised the RSS saffron flag on Parliament Hill. In 2020, the Peel District School Board removed one of its chairs for posting an Islamophobic tweet. It turns out the individual, who was also fired by his civilian employer, was affiliated with the HSS in Canada.
It is imperative that this Islamophobia resulting from an imported supremacist ideology not be allowed to grow and spread further in Canada. Our elected officials have to recognize this problem and consult with affected communities, whether Muslim, Sikh, or Hindu. They must not contribute to the problem.
Indeed, it is important to recognize that although the RSS network claims to represent all Hindus in India and abroad, it is an ideological and political group with a specific outlook that cannot and should not be conflated with all Hinduism or Hindus, who represent a vast tradition with millennia of history and diversity.
In the end and, if allowed to fester and grow, Canada risks becoming the scene for more episodes of intercommunal discord against groups deemed unacceptable or dangerous by the RSS, the BJP, and their various affiliates.
This can’t be allowed to happen. It is time to designate the RSS network, which has deep roots here, a terrorist organization under Canadian law and ban the organization in Canada.
