Listen Now
News

Canada Needs a new Iran Policy – Both Abroad and at Home

Among other necessary policy actions against Iran, Canada must do everything in its power to ensure that the days of being a sanctuary for the sanctioned are over.

By: /
3 July, 2025
At protests across Canada, the Iranian government has repeatedly been called out for human rights violations including the 2022 killing of Mahsa Amini, a 22-year-old woman who died while in police custody for not wearing a headscarf. Photo: Taymaz Valley/Wikimedia Commons.
Kevin Budning
By: Kevin Budning
Research Fellow at the Norman Paterson School of International Affairs

The decision last month by the United States (US) to join Israel in striking Iran’s nuclear program – potentially leading to a wider regional conflict – marks a pivotal moment for Canada to rethink both its foreign policy toward Iran and its domestic approach to individuals living here that support the regime.

For decades, Iran has been the world’s leading state sponsor of terrorism, providing financial and material support to militant groups such as Hamas in Gaza, Hezbollah in Lebanon, and the Houthis in Yemen. The regime has also backed armed militias in Iraq and propped up the former Assad government in Syria, which was responsible for the deaths of more than 200,000 civilians. Together, Iran’s proxies and allies have sown chaos across the Middle East as part of a calculated strategy to project power (both internally and regionally) while simultaneously deterring its adversaries.

Canada’s Approach to Iran 

Canada’s approach to Iran can best be described as one of cautious pragmatism – a strategy intended to signal disapproval of the regime without provoking direct confrontation or retaliatory measures against Canada’s Iranian diaspora. While well-intentioned, this approach has been muddled by enforcement and regulatory hurdles, limiting both its effectiveness and its ability to serve as a meaningful deterrent.

Take, for example, Canada’s sanctions on Iranian regime officials. Dozens of documented cases show that regime affiliates have been able to circumvent the law, exploiting Canada’s weak investigative, border, and intelligence capabilities. The legislation, which only applies to officials who served in the Iranian government since 2003, excludes a significant number of individuals who supported the regime or arrived in Canada prior to that date.

Similarly, Canada’s 2024 decision to designate the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), the paramilitary arm of the Iranian regime, as a terrorist organization was both delayed and politically mishandled.

The families of Flight PS752 spearheaded the initiative, arguing it would be the most effective way to hold the regime accountable for Tehran’s downing of the civilian airliner in January 2020. The Canadian government, however, initially listed only the Quds Force – a branch of the IRGC – and then spent several years debating the merits of a full designation. Some critics noted that the move was too challenging to implement, citing limitations in Canada’s Criminal Code, insufficient national security resources, and the government’s inability to effectively monitor or enforce such a designation. After prolonged delay and mounting public pressure, the measure was eventually passed in 2024 – far too late to send a clear and timely signal to Iran.

These types of contradictions have become an inadvertent hallmark of Canada’s official policy toward Iran. In 2012, Canada severed its diplomatic relations with the regime, yet now faces a crisis in which thousands of Canadians are stranded in Iran without access to consular services; it imposed export and trade controls despite minimal commercial activity due to pre-existing sanctions; and it remains a major funder of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), despite longstanding doubts about its ability to effectively and accurately monitor Iran’s nuclear activities.

As a middle power, Canada has struggled to strike the right balance – and identify where it can have the greatest impact – between challenging the direction of the Iranian regime and avoiding the further escalation of tensions.

Rhetoric vs. Reality

The greatest limitation in Canada’s Iran policy, then, is its failure to align domestic action with stated foreign policy values. While government officials routinely condemn Tehran, such as after the brutal killing of Mahsa Amini in September 2022, a 22-year-old woman who died in custody for not wearing a headscarf, they have been largely unable to stop IRGC affiliates and their families from entering Canada.

Investigators have revealed that hundreds of Iranian officials and affiliates are living in Canada. These kleptocrats, who have either worked within the regime or benefited from its corruption, have used Canada as a vehicle to transfer their wealth, driving up real estate prices in cities like Toronto and Vancouver as they look to park their money in safe, stable, and appreciating markets.

Moreover, activists, journalists, and members of the Iranian diaspora, especially those who fled state violence, report being surveilled and intimidated here in Canada. The problem is so endemic that Canada’s Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) has confirmed that there have been credible death threats against those who speak out against the regime, including a foiled assassination attempt targeting renowned human rights lawyer Irwin Cotler.

While the extent of the problem remains difficult to track, one grassroots volunteer organization, StopIRGC, has taken measures into their own hands by identifying over 91 suspected IRGC affiliates living in Canada. This revelation comes in addition to a recent warning from Canada’s Foreign Affairs Minister that Tehran may activate “sleeper cells” capable of engaging in threat related activities.

A Window of Opportunity

The recent strikes on Iran’s nuclear facilities represent a major international security test of Prime Minister Mark Carney’s leadership and a chance for him to define a clear and distinct foreign policy doctrine towards Iran. In particular, Carney should consider pursuing a two-track strategy: one that is bold and principled on the international stage and resolute in addressing threats here at home.

Internationally, Canada must be clear, intentional, and explicit in its calls for Iran to fully abandon its nuclear ambitions, demand that the current regime cannot remain in power, and continue to call for justice and accountability for the downing of Flight PS752.

While Prime Minister Carney and Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand tacitly endorsed the US strikes, affirmed that Iran must never be allowed to develop a nuclear weapon, and reiterated Israel’s right to self-defence, their simultaneous and reflexive calls for de-escalation and restraint reflect a continuation of Canada’s policy of cautious pragmatism. As seen throughout much of the Israel–Hamas war, Canada has attempted to strike a balance that placates all sides – a strategy that, in practice, sends a signal of policy incoherence and ambiguity.

The same applies to Canada’s continuing support of the IAEA. Should Canada continue to back this body, which Iran has now formally suspended cooperation with? Certainly, it must stop treating the agency as a panacea for addressing Iran’s nuclear ambitions. These positions need not be mutually exclusive: Canada can back international institutions and diplomatic engagement while also openly acknowledging the limitations of monitoring and inspection in a regime defined by deception, defiance, and non-compliance.

At home, Ottawa must address a perennial issue: the IRGC and regime loyalists using Canada as a safe haven. Beyond closing sanctions loopholes, Prime Minister Carney should commit to substantial investments in Canada’s intelligence, law enforcement, and border security to effectively identify, prosecute, and deport individuals with ties to the Iranian regime.

While some action is underway, including 66 ongoing investigations involving Iranians potentially inadmissible to Canada who have been granted visas, the scale of the threat, combined with the regime’s skilful tactics to deceive, have made it difficult for the authorities to keep pace. As a result, stricter immigration screening, enhanced tools to trace illicit financial flows, and robust funding for Canada’s commitments to countering foreign interference are no longer optional. Indeed, they are essential and long overdue.

Finally, Canada should heed the calls of the families of Flight PS752 victims and open a criminal investigation into the actions of those responsible. While legal and jurisdictional challenges exist, such a move would represent a meaningful step toward justice and accountability for Iran’s actions, offer a measure of closure to the victims’ families, and serve as a deterrent against future atrocities of this kind.

For too long, Canada’s policy toward Iran has been marked by risk-aversion and complacency. Now, as Iran finds itself in its weakest military and geopolitical position in decades, the opportunity is ripe for Canada to intensify pressure on the regime while doing everything it can to strengthen its own borders.

Most importantly, this includes a basic commitment to the approximately 300,000 Iranians who call Canada home: never again should they be forced to live alongside those who once served the very regime they risked everything to escape.

Before you click away, we’d like to ask you for a favour … 

 

Open Canada is published by the Canadian International Council, but that’s only the beginning of what the CIC does. Through its research and live events hosted by its 18 branches across the country, the CIC is dedicated to engaging Canadians from all walks of life in an ongoing conversation about Canada’s place in the world.

By becoming a member, you’ll be joining a community of Canadians who seek to shape Canada’s role in the world, and you’ll help Open Canada continue to publish thoughtful and provocative reporting and analysis.

Join us