Listen Now
News

Canada has endeared itself to generations of Indians – but time now to recharge ties

India-Canada bilateral relations are ripe with opportunities and can be buoyed by increasing trade, building education and security partnerships and sharing technology expertise.

By: /
24 February, 2025
Rabindranath Tagore (1861-1941) was a Bengali poet, novelist, playwright, painter, and educator. A commemorative bust of the poet was unveiled in Vancouver in 2002. Photo by Eguene Kim via Wikimedia Commons.
Seema Sengupta
By: Seema Sengupta
Kolkata based journalist and columnist

Way back in 1929, India’s Nobel laureate bard Rabindranath Tagore travelled to Canada to attend the Triennial Conference of the National Council of Education. “All my life I have devoted (myself) to the cause of education, and I do not see any factor which will lighten India’s load except the free and intensive dissemination of learning among the lower classes,” Tagore told the United Press in Shanghai, while on his way to Canada. “In this programme I look to America and Canada for aid, since it is in these countries that education has attained its highest form and the student class has the greatest freedom,” he declared. “In his long robe, with his beard and long curls falling upon his massive shoulders, he was an arresting figure,” The Gazette wrote, on his arrival in Victoria.

Tagore’s persona endeared him to Canada immediately. The revered poet, philosopher and polymath too, saw an opportunity for collaboration in education almost a century ago. As envisioned by him, an India-Canada education partnership would be built brick by brick over the years to help strengthen intellectual and cultural linkages through research, dialogue and exchanges. When the two countries formally established diplomatic relations in 1947, the key focus was on development assistance and education. In the years that followed the Shastri Indo-Canadian Institute was founded in 1967  to further promote academic collaboration, especially encouraging university level studies and research on India in Canadian educational institutions. The Institute also devised various programmes like fellowships and providing books and journals pertaining to India to the libraries of Canadian universities.

Education in Changing Times

Conceived as a soft diplomatic tool in a post-liberalized India, education built diplomatic bridges, with students playing the role of India’s cultural ambassadors. Studying abroad, especially in the West, has long been an aspiration for students  from India. Consequently, 1.33 million Indians travelled to foreign countries in 2024 for higher education, including 427,000 who arrived in Canada. In fact, Indian students made up 56.1 percent of all international enrolments in Canadian colleges in 2022-23.

But changes introduced by the Canadian government to its immigration policy in October 2024 have since made things difficult for Indians studying in Canada. A post-pandemic gap in supply and demand compelled the Canadian government to take decisive measures for attracting some of the world’s best and brightest talent to study and work in Canada, and then integrate them into the economy quickly. This translated into a faster economic recovery as robust immigration helped prevent recession, while contributing to Canada’s workforce. But a spike in Canada’s population, touching 41 million in April 2024, necessitated the Canadian government to  pause population growth in the short-term to achieve a well-managed and sustainable growth over the  long-term. Hence the October Immigration Levels Plan included for the first time in Canada’s history, controlled targets for temporary residents, specifically international students and foreign workers as well as permanent residents. Immigration, after all, had accounted for nearly 98 percent of population growth in 2023, 60 percent of which is attributed to temporary residents.

The Dilemma for Indian Students

Today, around 70 percent of students studying in Canada are from Punjab in India and use the Canadian education system as a pathway to becoming immigrants. The schools they attend are often substandard and run by Indians acting as conduits to find jobs. Most of these students also come from economically deprived families. Therefore, navigating a journey from a struggling life back home to a new environment on a foreign shore is not  easy. There are manifold challenges, deriving from financial pressure, difficulties in cultural and social adjustment, complexities of immigration and work policies, language barriers, vulnerability to exploitation and unfair treatment as well as the huge difference in the system of education. Also, the lack of a support system can drive students to mental trauma. The high cost of living and excessive tuition fees in Canada also compels students to work part-time – often in menial jobs while balancing a demanding academic schedule.

According to a former member of the Landlord and Tenant Board of the Government of Ontario, housing is also extremely expensive in large Canadian cities and a two-bedroom apartment can cost up to $3000 per month, and a single room in a basement around  $500-700 per month. There is a huge shortage of affordable housing as well. Some students even end up living in warehouses. This happens because very few are enrolled in accredited universities or community colleges, and even here resident accommodation is not cheap, and can cost more than $15,000 including meals. Given the fact that education in Canada is costly, how can students cope with the situation? 

In addition, India has alleged that dozens of Canadian colleges might also be linked to a scheme that illegally ferry’s students across the Canada-U.S. border, which amounts to human trafficking.

Addressing these many challenges requires a coordinated effort, with educational institutions, government policies and community initiatives being the key to ensuring that international students not only survive but thrive academically, socially and individually in Canada.

Survey Stirs up a Hornet’s Nest

A recent survey conducted by Thompson Rivers University (TRU) revealed that over 55 percent of international students face challenges in finding accommodation in Canada. These difficulties are either rooted in the high cost of living or racial discrimination, despite their contribution of billions of dollars to the Canadian economy and adding colour to the social fabric. The survey clearly indicates that in recent years, due to policy changes and several other factors, the problem of student accommodation, as noted above, has become more acute, further aggravating their vulnerability to exploitation and scams.

In 2024, Canada reduced undergraduate admissions by a whopping 35 percent and 10 percent for the year 2025 amid a growing domestic backlash over the number of people entering Canada. The reduction has impacted all levels of studies and is bleeding the education sector financially. Today, Canada is also faced with the prospect of a gigantic economic challenge in the form of steep American tariffs, apart from confronting the worst-ever workforce crisis, especially in the health sector. According to Ontario’s College of Family Physicians, 2.5 million people in Ontario alone do not have a family doctor – up from 1.8 million in 2020.  Across the country, this figure rises to 6.5 million.

Several instances of structured racism in parts of Canada have also come to the fore where foul language and intentional commenting have become common. The TRU survey highlighted an international student’s harrowing experience of a landlord threatening to cancel the student’s visa when trying to renegotiate the lease. Back in 2016, when asked about racism, 14 percent of students strongly agreed that they had faced racism in university while 21 percent only agreed and 25 percent disagreed. Based on the 2024 survey, this situation has not changed. 

While responding to the TRU survey, several students acknowledged that they encountered racism and exploitation during job hunting or for that matter searching for accommodation. The survey also exposed the deteriorating financial conditions of students as one third of international students flagged financial instability caused by rising rents and skyrocketing living costs. Diversifying scholarship opportunities, especially for students from marginalised regions, and enhancing support programmes for international students was recommended in the survey, which calls for proactive collaboration between the government and educational institutions.

A Political Storm in Bi-lateral Relations

“Do your best to prove yourselves good Canadians,” Tagore advised Indian immigrants who had made Canada their home. His call inspired many – including the sizable Sikh community that today makes up 2.1 percent of Canada’s population – to contribute positively to their new country. Today, Canada has the largest Sikh community outside India, but fault lines emerged when a section of the diaspora advocated for an independent Khalistan, a Sikh State, that, if realized, would break away from India’s Punjab province. The presence of Khalistan proponents in Canadian diplomatic events and subsequent allegation of India playing a part in orchestrating the killing of a prominent Canadian Sikh activist, and an alleged Khalistan sympathizer, added fuel to fire.

Despite these difficulties, India-Canada bilateral relations are ripe with opportunities and can be buoyed by increased trade, building education and security  partnerships and sharing technology expertise. Indeed, Canada’s prowess in advanced technologies, especially cybersecurity and aerospace offer co-development and joint manufacturing opportunities. Canada’s AI ecosystem, being a global leader, could also catalyse deep collaboration and innovation. Certainly, the relationship needs to expand by way of a formal trade agreement, which can unlock further socio-economic gains, but the Canada-India Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement negotiations, which began in 2010, have yet to result in an agreement. 

For Canada, India is a natural partner, bolstered by a large and visible diaspora. Therefore, it is time to reset and recharge strategic ties based on mutual trust and respect. Tagore was confident that Canada would come to raise the banner of invincible belief – in oneself and shared prosperity of the human race. He saw immense potential in Canada’s future: “Let her feel the scared dawn of her life, that the expectation of human destiny is upon her as upon other sister countries which have just entered into the cycle of their promise.”

Before you click away, we’d like to ask you for a favour … 

 

Open Canada is published by the Canadian International Council, but that’s only the beginning of what the CIC does. Through its research and live events hosted by its 18 branches across the country, the CIC is dedicated to engaging Canadians from all walks of life in an ongoing conversation about Canada’s place in the world.

By becoming a member, you’ll be joining a community of Canadians who seek to shape Canada’s role in the world, and you’ll help Open Canada continue to publish thoughtful and provocative reporting and analysis.

Join us